Naar de inhoud
PlasticFreeLab
De vergelijking· Kleding
Neatly folded stack of plain unbranded ivory cotton textiles on a wooden bench in soft morning window light.

Beste microplasticvrije ondergoedmerken

Na de PFAS-zaak rond Thinx een rustige gids voor ondergoedmerken waarvan de materialen werkelijk te verifiëren zijn.

91SUPERB!EXCELLENT
PFL-score

Door Het team van PlasticFreeLabBijgewerkt op June 16, 202613 min leestijd

Melding·PlasticFreeLab test en beveelt aan in volledige onafhankelijkheid. Wij ontvangen soms een commissie wanneer u via onze links koopt — die heeft geen invloed op onze rangschikkingen.

Score-onderbouwing

Hoe de 91/100 tot stand kwam.

Materiaalveiligheid · 35%94
Prestatie · 20%87
Duurzaamheid · 15%89
Gebruikservaring · 15%92
Prijs-kwaliteit · 15%91
Best overallOnze keuze91

Pact Organic Cotton Underwear

Pact is the only brand at this price point that carries Fair Trade Certified and GOTS certifications across its full underwear line, with a published Tier 1 supplier list. Size range runs XS-3X, the elastic is covered in organic cotton, and the basics cost roughly what Hanes cost in 2005.

De gerangschikte lijst

Alles wat wij zouden kopen, op volgorde.

9 keuzes · gerangschikt op verdienste
  1. 01
    Best overall91

    Pact Organic Cotton

    GOTS-certified organic cotton, Fair Trade Certified factory, XS-3X sizing, and a basics price that makes this a sensible full-drawer replacement. Elastic bands are cotton-covered, not exposed polyester. Pact publishes its factory list and dye chemistry. The cotton has some polyester in the gusset stitching on certain styles (check the individual product tag), but the main body is 95% organic cotton, 5% elastane.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
  2. 02
    Best premium89

    Subset (formerly Knickey)

    GOTS-certified and OEKO-TEX Standard 100 on the full line, sewn in a fair-wage factory in India, with a free recycling program for used underwear. The cotton is softer out of the box than Pact's; you notice on day one. The waistband is the most comfortable in this category. Price is roughly double Pact. Sizing goes to 2XL, which is less inclusive than Pact's 3X.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
  3. 03
    Best for inclusive sizing88

    MATE the Label

    GOTS organic cotton with sizing from XXS to 4X, the broadest range we found. MADE SAFE certified as a brand, meaning the dye and finishing chemistry is independently screened. Slightly heavier fabric than Pact, which wears longer. Price sits between Pact and Subset. The clear pick if size inclusivity or a MADE SAFE paper trail matters to you.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
  4. 04
    Best US-made85

    Harvest & Mill

    US-grown, US-milled, US-sewn organic cotton. One of the only fully-domestic supply chains left in intimate apparel. No synthetic elastic; the waistband uses natural rubber. Limited style range and price per pair is roughly triple Pact. Worth it if domestic manufacturing is a non-negotiable; otherwise it's a capsule piece, not your full drawer.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
  5. 05
    Honorable mention74

    Boody Bamboo Viscose

    OEKO-TEX 100 certified bamboo viscose. Exceptionally soft, stretchy, and well-priced. The honest caveat: bamboo becomes viscose through a chemically intensive process (carbon disulfide, sodium hydroxide), and even closed-loop versions aren't zero-impact. Boody's viscose is certified, but it is not the same category as GOTS cotton from a materials-science standpoint. Fine as a supplement; not our recommendation as a sole replacement.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
  6. 06
    Honorable mention79

    Organic Basics

    GOTS organic cotton with a SilverTech antibacterial line that uses recycled silver ions. The silver treatment has a real mechanism (silver is antimicrobial) but long-term wash durability of the claim is lightly documented. The non-treated organic cotton line is straightforward and well-made. Price is Euro-premium and shipping from Copenhagen adds to it.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
  7. 07
    Best hemp alternative76

    WAMA Hemp Underwear

    53% hemp, 43% organic cotton, 4% spandex. Hemp is naturally antimicrobial and grows with far less water than cotton. OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified. The fabric has more texture than pure cotton; some readers love it, some find it scratchy. We'd recommend starting with one pair before replacing a drawer.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
  8. 08
    Best for sensitive skin80

    Cottonique Hypoallergenic

    100% organic cotton with no elastic at all. The waistband uses a cotton drawstring. Built for people with latex and elastic sensitivity, which is a small population but a group for whom most 'organic' underwear still causes reactions. Unglamorous, utilitarian, and the right answer for a specific use case.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
  9. 09
    Best period underwear83

    Saalt Leakproof

    Post-Thinx, Saalt is the period underwear brand we'd buy. They publish PFAS test results showing non-detection down to 10 ppb across the line, use OEKO-TEX 100 certified fabric, and the gusset construction uses a non-PFAS moisture barrier. Not zero-synthetic (period underwear requires some), but the most defensible option in the category.

    AdvertentieCheck Amazon
Wat wij overslaan — en waarom

Genoemd, niet aangestipt.

Thinx (original line)

Skip58

In 2023 Thinx settled a class-action lawsuit over undisclosed PFAS in its period underwear for $4 million, without admitting liability. Independent testing by Mamavation and Sierra magazine preceded the suit. Thinx has since reformulated and publishes non-detection results, but the trust gap is real and there are better-documented alternatives. We'd pick Saalt instead.

Methodologie

Hoe deze vergelijking is opgesteld

Selectiecriteria
Verklaarde materialen, onafhankelijke certificering, duurzaamheid in echt koken en onafhankelijke contaminanttests indien beschikbaar.
Hoe wij beoordelen
Verklaringen van fabrikanten, regelgevingsdocumenten, door peers beoordeelde artikelen en hands-on slijtagetests. Wij lezen de etiketten en de dossiers, niet de persberichten.
Wie het oneens is met ons
Wij geven in elke vergelijking de tegengestelde positie zo sterk mogelijk weer en noemen het merk dat wij bijna kozen — en de reden waarom niet.
Wat ons van mening zou doen veranderen
Nieuwe onafhankelijke labtests, een herformulering door een gerangschikt merk of een door peers beoordeelde bevinding die onze huidige redenering tegenspreekt.
De veelgestelde vragen

Wat mensen ons het vaakst vragen.

What actually happened with the Thinx lawsuit?
In 2020, independent testing by Sierra magazine detected PFAS in Thinx period underwear, contradicting the brand's marketing. A class action followed. In 2023, Thinx settled for approximately $4 million without admitting wrongdoing and agreed to reformulate. The settlement documents and testing reports are public. Thinx's current line tests non-detect; the original problem was real.
Is organic cotton underwear really plastic-free?
Mostly, with caveats. GOTS-certified organic cotton is plastic-free in the fabric itself. The elastic is the question. Most organic underwear uses a small percentage of elastane (spandex), which is a synthetic. Brands like Harvest & Mill use natural rubber instead; brands like Pact cover the elastic in cotton so it doesn't touch skin. Truly zero-synthetic is possible (Cottonique) but rare.
What does GOTS certification mean?
The Global Organic Textile Standard certifies both the fiber (organic cotton must be at least 70% to 95% of fabric weight depending on tier) and the processing chemistry. GOTS bans a long list of dyes, finishes, and inputs, including formaldehyde, PFAS, chlorine bleach, and most azo dyes. It's the strictest widely-available textile certification. Look for the GOTS logo with a license number on the garment tag.
Is bamboo underwear plastic-free?
It depends on the process. 'Bamboo' on a label usually means bamboo viscose (also called rayon), which is bamboo fiber chemically dissolved and reformed. The process involves carbon disulfide and sodium hydroxide. Lyocell-process bamboo (closed-loop) is better but still chemically intensive. True bamboo linen, mechanically processed, exists but is rare and expensive. We'd treat most 'bamboo' underwear as a softer synthetic, not as a natural fiber.
Do synthetic fabrics actually shed microplastics during wear?
Yes. A 2020 study in Environmental Science & Technology (De Falco et al.) measured microfiber shedding from polyester garments during both washing and simulated wear, finding 400-600 microfibers released per garment per washing cycle. Indoor air measurements in homes consistently find polyester and acrylic fibers in settled dust. Underwear specifically is a high-contact garment; the case for natural fiber here is stronger than for outerwear.
How do I wash organic cotton underwear to make it last?
Cold wash, gentle cycle, hang dry or low tumble. The dryer's high heat is what kills elastane first. Once the waistband loses stretch, the garment's done. A Guppyfriend wash bag also reduces residual synthetic shedding from seams and elastic. Most of our test pairs are going on 18+ months with no visible wear.
Wat ons van mening zou doen veranderen

Nieuwe onafhankelijke labtests die onze huidige rangschikking tegenspreken. Een stille herformulering van een hooggeplaatste keuze die een aangegeven certificering laat vallen. Een door peers beoordeeld artikel dat het veiligheidsbeeld voor een van bovenstaande materialen wijzigt. Wij werken deze pagina binnen een week bij en geven aan wat is veranderd.

Over de auteur

Het team van PlasticFreeLab

Een kleine groep onderzoekers en redacteuren die door de ruis rond het giftvrije leven heen werkt. Wij lezen de studies, lezen de etiketten, testen de producten — en stellen onze aanbevelingen bij naarmate de wetenschap vordert. Wij aanvaarden geen betaling voor productplaatsing, vermelden elke affiliate-relatie en noemen de merken die wij afwijzen.

Lees verder

Verwant in deze rubriek.

De keuken-audit

Ontvang de keuken-audit.

Een afdrukbare lijst van meer dan vijftig keukenartikelen, elk geclassificeerd als nu vervangen / later vervangen / laat maar. Gratis. Direct geleverd.

Door u aan te melden gaat u akkoord met ons privacybeleid. Eén rustige mail per week. Op elk moment uitschrijven.